I’m almost at fuming level. First Steve Clarke, and now Andre Villas Boas; when’s this streak going to end?
It’s all very well and good the Premier League being competitive, and it shows by the reactions of players, crowds and managers on and off the pitch with the noise, passion, commitment and attitude. But does it need to be shown so openly by chairmen and owners?
You get the feeling there is panic and worry among the prawn sandwich brigade when they see their team lose three or four on the bounce, so what do they do? Sack the manager.
In Clarke’s case, West Brom are hovering just two points clear of safety having picked up zero out of a possible 12 in their last four league games, failing to score in the last two. But look further beyond that, and you see a 2-2 draw away to Chelsea - which should have been a 2-1 victory were it not for a controversial penalty in the last minute that rescued the hosts - and an even more impressive 2-1 victory at Old Trafford against Manchester United at the end of September, the Baggies’ first since 1978.
To be fair to West Brom though, what do they fully expect? The loss at home to Norwich is far from acceptable, but losing 1-0 away to Cardiff isn’t a result that a manager can be judged on, especially with a home clash against Hull coming up on the weekend. Perhaps if Clarke were to lose that his position may be reviewed, but ultimately it’s got to come down to their position at the end of the season, and that is not going to be in the bottom 3.
Spurs, meanwhile, have had a more difficult time recently, but that is life in the Premier League. Ok, they should not be losing 5-0 at home to Liverpool (even with 10 men), or 6-0 away to City, but before that they had the best defence in the league! The tightest at least, and this run just seems like a blip, so was it fair for AVB to lose his job?
Let’s go back to the summer, and even the end of last season. Spurs finished fifth, one point behind Arsenal (4th) and three behind Chelsea (3rd), so not really a bad season at all given it was AVB’s first. However Bale’s form came at a price, £80million in fact as he was sold to Real Madrid, but Spurs went on to spend £100million on new players, including £30million on Erik Lamela from Roma, £7million on FC Twente’s Nacer Chadli, and £26million on Roberto Soldado. In addition to those were Vlad Chiriches, Christian Eriksen, Paulinho and Etienne Capoue. A staggering five new midfield players, and it’s no wonder the young Portugese manager didn’t know his best team.
But the question remains, just how many of those players did AVB actually want? How many of them were Franco Baldini’s signings? Perhaps the answer lies with the small number of appearances made by Lamela, Chadli and Capoue.
Excuse the pun, but one of the most striking statistics from the weekend was that Spurs registered no shots on target; surely that says something about the players more than the manager?
But my conclusion has to fall to panic on Daniel Levy’s part, or embarrassment following the defeats to City and Liverpool. Just look at other aspects to the season; they have a 100% record in the Europa League, and are through to the last-32, a win against West Ham on Wednesday will see them through to the semi-final of the League Cup, so are Spurs really doing that badly?
Manchester United are certainly in a worse position in the league, and have suffered embarrassing league defeats to City, West Brom, Everton and Newcastle (and were close to losing at home to Stoke too!), so why hasn’t David Moyes’ position been endangered? I think Jamie Redknapp may have had a point in blaming the Spurs board’s policies…
At this point it is probably fair to give credit to Norwich for sticking with Chris Hughton, despite their heavy losses, because having backed him in the summer, they are giving him the chance to get it right instead of moving back to square one, and that is just what Tottenham have now done, so they can forget any chances of finishing in the top four, and for me even winning a trophy. At least under AVB they had those chances.
So what now for Spurs? They need a manager, and quick, because if they don’t get settled and start picking points up soon, they will have absolutely no hope, and European football next season could be a very big ask. Not to mention their difficult start to the New Year!